3.5 stars. I liked the different take on the supernatural in this book. It was something that I hadn't seen before and was rather refreshing. Loved Will and Lily. Both were excellent characters. Will has some swoony lines and Lily injects humor as the best friend. I'm not sure how I feel about the MC, Scarlett. I get the reasons behind her depression, but to me, something seemed off. The last half of the book becomes very religious. Personally, I'm not super religious, to each their own and all that. However, I started to feel like I was studying for a test instead of reading for fun. Overall, I enjoyed the book and I'll definitely be reading the next one.