The first half of this book is super confusing. I had no idea wtf was going on most of the time and I almost gave up on it. Only the fact that everyone loved it kept me reading. I loved Jonah and the trip to the city. I loved that the tunnel was real. And I loved the maniacal way the story was told, once I understood where it was going. There's just something about it that I didn't love, something that everyone else found in the story that I didn't. Maybe after I think about it and digest, I'll change my rating.