I'm gonna say 4 1/2 stars. I liked this one more than the first one. I was most happy for the fact that there wasn't a horrible love triangle or any sort of breakup/separation for Brendan and Emma. I loved the added POVs, even if it was just for a few chapters. It was very effective for the story and a different way to advance the plot when Emma wasn't around. Not to mention there was the bonus of seeing Brendan through the eyes of someone who's not in love with him. I would absolutely love more to this series, but I'm quite content knowing that Emma and Brendan got their happily ever after.